DelphiFAQ Home Search:

Should I pay off my mortgage faster by adding extra principal?

 

comments82 comments. Current rating: 4 stars (21 votes). Leave comments and/ or rate it.

Question:

I have been paying my mortgage for 5 years and now some extra income. Should I make additional principal payments? My mortgage is a 30-year fixed at 6.25% interest.

And how does the taxation play a role here? I am in the 25% tax bracket.


Answer:

If you prepay your mortgage or increase the monthly payment to pay of quicker, then your savings are 6.25% annually. What would you do with the money if you would NOT use it to pay down the mortgage?

You could put it in CD accounts which will yield maybe 4 to 5% interest. The benefit is that you are more flexible in case of an emergency (loss of job, health related bills).

There is zero risk in paying down the mortgage, and also zero risk in buying CD accounts, but the return of the mortgage is higher than the CD accounts.

If you buy stock, your risk is substantially higher. It is basically gambling. Your possible return is higher as well.
Investing in mutual funds on average yields 9% in the long term. However, in the short term, you may take losses. The risk is substantially lower than buying stock though.

The right decision also has to do with your age and your life, its schedule and what you expect to do in the future.

Taxation plays almost no role in the decision of whether to pay off early or invest otherwise.

Let's say you pay additional principal. That means you save interest in future payments. The interest is tax-deductible. So one could argue that the real cost of the loan is not 6.25% but 6.25% * 0.75 (since you are in the 25% tax bracket) = 4.7%

However, if your mutual fund yields 9% profit, you also pay 25% tax on that. So the effective profit is only 9% * 0.75 = 6.75%
Similarly a CD account yielding 4% effectively only returns 3% (4% * 0.75 = 3%)

The only exception is if your investment is pretax as a 401k plan or a tax-exempted bond. In that case you should compare the bond's full return against the prorated mortgage interest.

In your specific case - 6.25% is a pretty low rate. If you wait a little longer, you may find zero-risk investments such as savings accounts that will beat that return.


And now a completely different perspective on this topic:

If your mortgage is fully paid off, and your house gets hit by a hurricane or earthquake, then you are in more trouble than your neighbor who had only 10% equity in his place. You just lost all your house and try now to get money from the insurance. If the bank has the equity (and you have the mortgage) then the bank will deal with the insurance.

And there is also the thought that free and clear owners may more likely be subject to lawsuits if something happens to someone on your property. Not sure how relevant this is but I thought I should add it.


Comments:

You are on page 4 of 6, other pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6
2009-07-31, 23:02:58   (updated: 2009-07-31, 23:09:35)
Texas,H-town from United States  
Here's my situation...I want to upgrade in house with in the next year or so. I have a 4.5% 15 year fixed with a balance of 74k with approximately 51k equity. I have 16k cash to put down on a new house today if I had to. Current motgage is 830/month.

Option 1: Put down 16000 extra on the mortgage. Brings the principle down to 57k. Pay 5830 every month until August, then in December put down a final 3415 and have the loan paid off at one year on the dot. Accumulated interest totals out to 1635 in lieu of 16k if I were to carry out the loan with normal terms. Then I'd have somewhere in the neighborhood of 125k to put down on the new house.

Option 2: Find the house I want now and drop the 16k that I have in cash for a down payment. Now I have to worry about floating the mortgage for the old home until someone buys it. Once I find a buyer I can dump the equity into the new home. This new home will most likely be in the neighborhood of 225-300k.

What would you do?
This image was also posted here:
Should I pay off my mortgage faster by adding extra principal?



Keywords:
2009-07-31, 23:09:09
anonymous from United States  

This image was also posted here:
Should I pay off my mortgage faster by adding extra principal?



Keywords:
2009-08-10, 11:33:37
anonymous from United States  
If you have a 30 year fixed mortgage and double the payment every month, will it be payed off in six years?
2009-08-13, 17:12:02
[hidden] from United Kingdom  
I just paid off my mortgage yesterday! I had my Mortgage for 8 years. In febuary 09 I decided to just pay the sucker off and started using 100% of my income to pay it off. It is the best decision I have ever made...With some savings and all my income it took me six months to payoff the balance of 111k. The peace of mind is priceless and its still sinking in. There were a few times early on in my mortgage where I almost lost my house (Company I contracted from went into BK). The reason I bring that up is you must remember when you have a mortgage you DO NOT own your house.If you get hurt or sick your up a creek because the bank is a business and will take your house away in a flash. If you can make any extra payments to principle DO IT!! You take off years everytime you do. I feel stupid I waited 5 years before I really started to make large principle payments. I should have done it from the beginning of my Mortgage. I have no Debt at all now. All of the money I earn from here and forevermore is mine!
PAY THAT SUCKER OFF ASAP>>>OWN YOUR LIFE!!
2009-08-16, 21:24:32
anonymous from United States  
happygirl- your situation depends on the rate you can get for the 15-year mortgage you are looking at. chances are it won't be less than 5%, but you can ask the bank about that (you will also have to include the refinance fees when you calculate your 'new' interest rate). if this rate, that the lender can and will calculate for you if you ask them, is more than 5%, it makes more sense to stay with your current mortgage and use the 50K to pay down your principal.

keep in mind that 15 and 30 year products are the same idea. if you pay down your principal, increase your monthly payments, etc., you can turn the products into whatever schedule you want- the bank might not like it but prepayment risk is one that they have to take. if you want to pay off your remaining balance in 15 years, i would suggest checking an online calculator for a 15-year mortgage for your remaining balance (115K after your 50K payment) at your current 5% interest rate. you can then begin to pay those payments instead of your minimum and your mortgage will be paid off in 15 years (or whatever time frame you would like). if you can get lower than a 5% rate, NET of refinancing fees, and you know you can make the extra payments, then refinancing would be your best option.
2009-09-20, 20:45:05   (updated: 2009-09-20, 20:48:08)
craig@findahomeinutah.com from Salt Lake City, United States  
Great String!!
After 35 years of paying mortgages, buying several houses, having been a loan officer and currently being a Realtor, I have a strong opinion on this matter.

It totally makes sense to pay off your home before retirement. Who wants to be burdened with a house payment after retirement?

The question is; how and when do we want to pay off the mortgage?
There are times when you can receive a better interest rate by investing your 'extra money'.
There are times when it is safer to just pay off your mortgage early with additional principle payments. I have tried both. The key is to not spend the extra money but to invest it.

I bought investment property with some of my home's equity and my tenants are paying off the new mortgage. That works great as long as business is good and I have no vacancies.

I invested in the stock market and got burned, big time. I would have been better off making additional principle payments.

I refinanced at a lower rate and had the Lender pay for the closing costs with his commission. I took a higher interest rate than I could have so he could pay my closing costs. It worked much better than refinancing and rolling my costs into the loan.

I currently have a 5.375% interest rate loan for 30 years. I double or tripple my payments with a goal of having it all paid off by the time I reach 65 or 70. I am currently 59.

If times get tough, I can make my low, long term payment. When times are flush I make additional principle payments. The key is, get out of debt and make investments.

Best Wishes & keep learning
Craig




Keywords:
2009-09-23, 14:02:04
anonymous from United States  
Where do find a reliable mortgage calculator that keeps up with additional principle payments duducted from mort. and gives the final results of this?
2009-10-16, 19:38:44   (updated: 2009-10-16, 20:17:47)
anonymous  
I would like to know if paying a extra $300 a month on my $308,000 20 year mortgage is better than making a onetime payment to principal of $72,000.
2009-10-16, 20:00:19
ldane  
I just refinanced from 30 yr (28 yrs left)6.625% to 20 yr 5.5% for $308,000. I am paying a extra $300 per month, but I am able to to do more. If I make a onetime payment of say $72,000 is that better, the same, or worse than paying the $300 extra a month? I forgot to mention that I'm 56 years old in relatively good health, and earn around $150,000 a year. I don't know a lot about this finance stuff, but I realise there are some things that can be done to shorten the life of the mortgage, therefore the amount of money paid out. I don't want to be 76 before my mortgage is paid off because if something were to happen it would burden my wife of 36 years.
2009-10-22, 17:37:20
anonymous from United States  
if i take my amortization schedule an pay my monthly payment plus next month principle every month for life of the loan. how long would it take to pay off my loan. It is a 30 year mortgage @ 4.875 fixed
You are on page 4 of 6, other pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6

 

 

NEW: Optional: Register   Login
Email address (not necessary):

Rate as
Hide my email when showing my comment.
Please notify me once a day about new comments on this topic.
Please provide a valid email address if you select this option, or post under a registered account.
 

Show city and country
Show country only
Hide my location
You can mark text as 'quoted' by putting [quote] .. [/quote] around it.
Please type in the code:

Please do not post inappropriate pictures. Inappropriate pictures include pictures of minors and nudity.
The owner of this web site reserves the right to delete such material.

photo Add a picture: